t-j-watt.jpg
Getty Images

The New York Jets were determined to spend money this week, signing wide receiver Garrett Wilson and cornerback Sauce Gardner to lucrative contract extensions on consecutive days. Wilson's $130 million deal ties him to New York through 2030, making him one of the NFL's top 10 highest-paid pass catchers. Gardner's $120.4 million agreement is equally massive, making him the league's highest-paid cover man in terms of average annual value ($30.1 million) going into the 2025 season.

Then on Thursday, the Steelers locked down star pass rusher T.J. Watt by giving him a three-year, $123 million deal -- making him the highest-paid non-quarterback in NFL history in terms of annual average value ($41 million).

There are all kinds of ways to evaluate NFL contracts. Guaranteed money often means much more than surface-level extension numbers, given that teams often terminate or renegotiate deals early. And only new-money averages tend to be factored into widespread conversations around "highest-paid players," even though existing portions of contracts are factored into how players are actually paid over the life of their respective deals.

Even so, we can get a general sense of each position's market by examining the latest per-year averages in free-agent contracts and actual extensions. So here's a look at the highest-paid players according to that metric:

Note: Contract figures are courtesy of Over the Cap and Spotrac.

QB: Dak Prescott ($60 million per year)

Dak Prescott
DAL • QB • #4
CMP%64.7
YDs1978
TD11
INT8
YD/Att6.92
View Profile
  • Signed in: 2024 | Signed through: 2028
  • Total contract: 4 years, $240 million

RB: Saquon Barkley ($20.6 million)

Saquon Barkley
PHI • RB • #26
Att345
Yds2005
TD13
FL1
View Profile
  • Signed in: 2025 | Signed through: 2028
  • Total contract: 2 years, $41.2 million

FB: C.J. Ham ($4.325 million)

C.J. Ham
MIN • FB • #30
View Profile
  • Signed in: 2023 | Signed through: 2029
  • Total contract: 2 years, $8.65 million

WR: Ja'Marr Chase ($40.25 million)

Ja'Marr Chase
CIN • WR • #1
TAR175
REC127
REC YDs1708
REC TD17
FL0
View Profile
  • Signed in: 2025 | Signed through: 2029
  • Total contract: 4 years, $161 million

TE: George Kittle ($19.1 million)

George Kittle
SF • TE • #85
TAR94
REC78
REC YDs1106
REC TD8
FL0
View Profile
  • Signed in: 2025 | Signed through: 2029
  • Total contract: 4 years, $76.4 million

OT: Tristan Wirfs ($28.12 million)

  • Signed in: 2024 | Signed through: 2029
  • Total contract: 5 years, $140.6 million

OG: Trey Smith ($23.5 million)

  • Signed in: 2025 | Signed through: 2028
  • Total contract: 4 years, $94 million
Chiefs make Trey Smith highest-paid offensive guard in NFL with four-year, $94 million extension
Jordan Dajani
Chiefs make Trey Smith highest-paid offensive guard in NFL with four-year, $94 million extension

C: Creed Humphrey ($18 million)

  • Signed in: 2024 | Signed through: 2028
  • Total contract: 4 years, $72 million

EDGE: T.J. Watt ($41 million)

T.J. Watt
PIT • OLB • #90
View Profile
  • Signed in: 2025 | Signed through: 2028
  • Total contract: 3 years, $123 million
Steelers, T.J. Watt agree to contract extension that makes him highest-paid non QB in NFL history, per report
Bryan DeArdo
Steelers, T.J. Watt agree to contract extension that makes him highest-paid non QB in NFL history, per report

DL: Chris Jones ($31.75 million)

  • Signed in: 2024 | Signed through: 2028
  • Total contract: 5 years, $158.75 million

LB: Fred Warner ($21 million)

  • Signed in: 2025 | Signed through: 2029
  • Total contract: 3 years, $63 million

CB: Sauce Gardner ($30.1 million)

  • Signed in: 2025 | Signed through: 2030
  • Total contract: 4 years, $120.4 million
Jets make Sauce Gardner highest-paid cornerback in NFL history with $120.4 million extension, per report
Jordan Dajani
Jets make Sauce Gardner highest-paid cornerback in NFL history with $120.4 million extension, per report

S: Kerby Joseph ($21.5 million)

  • Signed in: 2025 | Signed through: 2029
  • Total contract: 4 years, $86 million

K: Harrison Butker ($6.4 million)

  • Signed in: 2024 | Signed through: 2028
  • Total contract: 4 years, $25.6 million

P: Michael Dickson ($4.05 million)

  • Signed in: 2025 | Signed through: 2029
  • Total contract: 4 years, $16.2 million

Breakdown by position

RankPositionTop AAV

1

QB

$60M

2

WR

$40.25M

3

EDGE

$40M

4

DL

$31.75M

5

CB

$30.1M

6

OT

$28.12M

7

OG

$23.5M

8

S

$21.5M

9

LB

$21M

10

RB

$20.6M

11

TE

$19.1M

12

C

$18M

13

K

$6.4M

14

FB

$4.325M

15

P

$4.05M

Breakdown by team

RankTeamHighest-Paid Players

1

Chiefs

4

2

49ers

2

3

T-9

1