Hill (9-6) took the loss after serving up six runs on eight hits while walking one and striking out four over 3.2 innings against the Diamondbacks on Tuesday.
Hill came back down to earth after flirting with perfection in his last start. The 37-year-old only threw 99 pitches in his impressive start against the Pirates last Wednesday, so fatigue can be ruled out as a possible explanation for Tuesday's implosion. Hill hasn't been as dominant as he was during his 2016 renaissance, but he has provided enough fantasy value to be useful with a 3.74 ERA and 10.6 K/9 through 20 starts. The veteran southpaw will get a chance to redeem himself in a rematch with Arizona on Monday.